Friday, 28 September 2018

The Myth of Pelagianism

The Myth of Pelagianism is a new book by Ali Bonner, a member of the department of Anglo-Saxon, Norse and Celtic 

Pelagius is the first known British author, famous for his defence of free will as the Roman empire disintegrated. He advocated two ideas: that human nature was inclined to goodness, and that man had free will. After a campaign to vilify him he was excommunicated in ad 418 for allegedly inventing a dangerous new heresy, and his name was made a by‑word for wilful arrogance. The narrative of Pelagius the heresiarch has held sway unchallenged for 1,600 years, but it is the story written by those who sought to have him condemned, and it is untrue.

My research into the manuscript transmission of Pelagius’ works has revealed their largescale copying and wide availability across Europe throughout the middle ages. This was possible because his works travelled under false attributions to other Christian writers, and under these other names, Pelagius was a highly influential author. To better understand this phenomenon, I researched the history of the ideas that Pelagius advocated and found that he defended interpretations of the Bible that were mainstream in contemporary literature. In The Myth of Pelagianism I set out the evidence to show that Pelagius proposed nothing new; he repeated ideas that had been common in Christian literature for decades. This textual evidence suggests that Pelagius was entirely unoriginal and did not invent a new heresy as his opponents alleged. Instead he defended what was the mainstream understanding of Christianity at the time; far from being the leader of a separatist group, he was one of many propagandists for the ascetic movement, which was a broad movement that took many forms and was based on encouraging Christians to live the kind of life Christ advocated. Many factors contributed to the large scale of the copying of Pelagius’ works, but the critical cause was the fact there was no doctrinal difference between Pelagius’ writings and much other ascetic literature by writers whose names had no label of heresy attached. Medieval readers could not see a doctrinal difference between Pelagius’ writings and other ascetic literature, such as Jerome’s writings, because there was no difference. Pelagius’ distinguishing characteristic was that he was a particularly persuasive writer: he was good at getting inside his readers’ heads, and 1,600 years later he still is.

The accusation of heresy against Pelagius should be seen in the context of sociological analysis of the creation of deviance and of the function of heresy in religion. Pelagius is a perfect example of the constructed nature of heresy. Because his works survive we can see the gulf between what he wrote and the ideas his opponents attributed to him. We can also see why they created a misleading narrative about Pelagius. In order to install the doctrines they espoused in their version of Christianity, they needed to delegitimise the contemporary mainstream view of human nature and free will. Inventing a heretical group, labelling it, stigmatising it, creating a false narrative about Pelagius and disseminating it in a campaign of lobbying powerful people: these were the techniques used to transfer authority to their own version of Christianity and their own literary output. This was a battle for authority within the Church, and political power determined the outcome. The Christian scriptural expert against whose ideas Pelagius defended the mainstream view, and who had most to lose if Pelagius’ defence of the goodness of human nature and free will were allowed to stand, was Augustine, bishop of Hippo in North Africa. Augustine and his colleagues lobbied the western Roman emperor to issue an Imperial edict condemning Pelagius and to put pressure on the Pope to overturn his previous acquittal of Pelagius. When the Pope succumbed to the emperor’s pressure nineteen Italian bishops resigned their sees in protest at the improper process, requesting that the theological issues be decided in open discussion by a council of bishops. But power determined the content of doctrine on these questions, and their objections were ignored.           

Pick up a book or search online and you will find the same story: that Pelagius was responsible for a heresy which privileged human free will to the exclusion of God’s role in human decisions and epitomised arrogance. This is not true. Instead the evidence shows that ‘Pelagianism’ did not exist. The term ‘Pelagianism’ should be abandoned because it imports a false paradigm into discussion. A more accurate terminology is available: we can refer to the ascetic movement and the fervour with which many Christians expressed their own variations on the theme of living as Christ enjoined. The ideas that were successfully installed in 418 when Pelagius was condemned were that mankind was inherently sinful and was not in control of his moral choices, and that Pelagius taught that man could achieve virtue without divine help and personified arrogance. In 2018 it is time to revise our understanding of the history of Christianity in late antiquity to bring it into line with the manuscript and textual  evidence that has now been presented, so that as Éric Rebillard has counselled, we do not ‘reify groups under the influence of polemical source texts’.      

The Myth of Pelagianism by Dr Ali Bonner, Lecturer in Celtic History in the department of Anglo‑Saxon, Norse, and Celtic, was published by OUP in August 2018.

A link to a feature in The Church Times:


  1. Do you need Personal Finance?
    Business Cash Finance?
    Unsecured Finance
    Fast and Simple Finance?
    Quick Application Process?
    Finance. Services Rendered include,
    *Debt Consolidation Finance
    *Business Finance Services
    *Personal Finance services Help
    Please write back if interested with our interest rate
    contact us
    For call or watssap us +15165910949

  2. Welcome to the official website of our company to clean apartments, houses, villas and shops in Saudi Arabia This is because we are the best home services company at the moment and by the testimony of our valued customers, the workers who work in the company have a very high experience in the field of cleaning in general, as well as we will give you cleanliness of the highest quality and the lowest prices with the testimony of customers, our goal is to satisfy our customers to the highest degree possible and thanks to God always First of all, thanks to the workers and technicians, we were able to satisfy all the customers who contracted with the company and contacted them, because we specialize in cleaning, sewerage and transport of luggage just contact us and you will notice that your house as if it is completely new from the intensity of cleanliness.
    شركة الصفرات للتنظيف بالرياض
    شركة الصفرات لتنظيف الخزانات بالرياض
    شركة الصفرات لمكافحة الحشرات بالرياض
    شركة الصفرات لنقل الاثاث بالرياض
    شركة الصفرات لكشف التسربات بالرياض
    شركة تنظيف بالمدينة المنورة
    شركة تنظيف بينبع

  3. Thenutritionsclinic The world of nowadays is scientifically, technologically, educationally advanced and the traits around us are in leaps and boundaries. socalled inventions and improvements are just rediscoveries of what our wonderful forefathers have recorded of their vedic scripts. Extra awesome is the fact that even as this rapidity and improvements have brought global warming, incurableunfathomable illnesses, environmental deterioration, area pollutants & even danger of extinction as the byproducts & sideeffects; the innovations and methodologies of indian vedic pupils had been without all this negativity.

  4. Exotic cart is a well known prefilled THC oil cartridge, and stoners from the west to east drift use them. ... Our cartscontain premium lab tried THC Oil which these days, is hard to find. 123movies Our pre-filled cannabis cartridges are ideal for vaping Maryjane in a hurry.

  5. Thanks for sharing this Amazing Post.
    If you are facing any problem with YouTube not working your device like smart TV or Roku device etc. so you can contact us, Our YouTube Activate customer care team 24*7 available for resolving your issues, furthermore gives the safest solution by simple steps.

  6. Canon Printer in Error State is definitely not a peculiar circumstance for its user. For different known and obscure reasons, printers go into a error state and quit reacting. Notwithstanding, the "Ordinance printer error state" is the most confounded and obscure one as you have no away from of what precisely you need to manage.
    why is my canon printer always in error state

  7. شركة سما الصقر
    نحن متخصصون في أعمال كشف التسربات المياة في الرياض وكذلك في أعمال الترميمات وأعمال ترميمات السباكة وأعمال الدهانات وتنفيذ أحدث أنواع الديكورات , وكذلك متخصصون في أعمال العزل الحراري للأسطح والعزل المائي لأسطح العقارات والفلل في الرياض وعموم أنحاء المملكة العربية السعودية
    افضل شركة ترميم بالرياض
    شركة ترميم
    شركة كشف تسربات المياه بالرياض
    ترميم حمامات
    كشف تسربات المياة بالرياض
    شركة ترميم حمامات
    شركة ترميم فلل بالرياض
    شركة كشف تسربات مياه بالرياض
    كشف تسربات بالرياض
    شركة ترميم منازل بالرياض

  8. Hey, United Kingdom is considered to be a large nation because of its total area. Its total land area is 243,610 km² (approx. 94,058 mi²). Continental shelf of United Kingdom is approximately 722,891 km² (around 279,108 mi²). United Kingdom is located in Europe. Europe is a continent whose borders date back to the period of antiquity.

  9. Do you need a legitimate, honest, reputable and urgent loan?Your search for legitimate loan ends here today for we are here to satisfy your financial needs.If you have been refused a loan by banks or financial institution for any reasons do not worry anymore about your financial problems for we are the solution to your financial misfortune.We have provided Billions (different currencies) in business loans to over 32,000 business owners.We use our own designated risk technology to provide you with the right business loan so you can grow your business. we offer loan of all types with a low interest rate and also duration  to pay back the loan Do you have a bad credit? Do you need money to pay bills? or you feel is it necessary to start a new business? Do you have an unfinished project due to poor funding? Do you need money to invest in any specialty that will benefit you? ISLAMIC REFINANCING LOAN COMPANY
     aim is to provide excellent professional financial services e_mail:[]

  10. Wow amazing article.Thank for sharing such a nice post.i like it so much.Check Office Furniture Miami

  11. Hi There! How you have been doing? Did you understand everything expressed in the above write-up? Well certainly, I have and I want to praise the author because I can see talent here. The author has explained everything from scratch without going into too many details and that is a very hard skill to master. I am a digital content writer as well, and I have experience working in pre-eminent companies such as Webroot and Norton. But I still make mistakes, and I like criticism because it helps me improve my work. So, go to the following link and help me become a better version of myself:

  12. Travelers are concerned about many airlines' inflexibility, unpredictability, and last-minute cancellations. They are unaware of the cancellation fees that apply if you cancel at the last minute or the fees that apply if you book your trip before it is completed. Ural Airlines, on the other hand, has a different cancellation policy. According to Ural Airlines cancellation policy, any change in your travel plans gives you the option of cancelling your reservation and receiving a refund for the portion of the ticket that you have not utilized.

  13. The new report by Expert Market Research titled, ‘Global Smart Display Market Report and Forecast 2022-2027’, gives an in-depth analysis of the global Smart Display Market, assessing the market based on its segments like type, display size, resolution, growth end use, and major regions. The report tracks the latest trends in the industry and studies their impact on the overall market. Smart display technology has been gaining traction over the last few years. The growing usage of smart displays in residential and public facilities such as retail shops and the increasing number of infrastructural improvements such as smart homes and increasing demand for smart vehicles are contributing to the market growth. The major players in the market are Alpine Electronics, Inc., Japan Display Inc., Leyard Optoelectronic Co., Ltd., Alphabet Inc., and LG Electronics Inc., among others. The report covers the market shares, capacities, plant turnarounds, investments, expansions, and mergers and acquisitions, among other latest developments of these market players.